Wow, a clue I know right off the bat. Those are a little rare. Well it's still open to interpretation.

It's after your set began glowing with green,

Obviously something about the Muppets. Sam and Friends was 1955 and Sesame Street started in 1969 (both out of bounds).

The Muppet Show started airing in 1976. But there were pilots in 1974 and 1975.

Vapor doesn't give clues that include outliers like pilots and such so I think 76 is the correct clue.

vkimo wrote :

Vapor doesn't give clues that include outliers like pilots and such so I think 76 is the correct clue.
-end quote

Correct. Using such things could make it too confusing.

When Dark came to
reSide on screen and wrought unsettling Tales, choose not from then for
you will be distraught by your epic fail.

Tales From the Dark Side, excluding the pilot, aired from 1984 to 1988.

Pureheart the Powerful, and Archie's Super Teens. Never have I ever read an Archie book.

Pureheart the Powerful was from 1965, so it's out of the range. I think Archie's Super Teens is the more likely answer to the hint. However, it was very short lived with all the issues published in 1994.

Don't Vote Dates when there would be, new ways to watch our favorite scenes.

The only thing I can think of are how DVDs lets you watch your favorite scenes. However, I don't know what the Don't Vote Dates part at the beginning would actually mean.

wikipedia wrote :

The DVD format went on sale in Japan in 1995, in the United States in 1997...
-end quote

So before one of those

1994

I'll say 1995